Stupidity in Design - Most Industrial Equipment/Lawnmowers
#1
Senior Member



Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Suburb of Sugar Tit SC
Posts: 14,493
Received 9,282 Likes
on
5,026 Posts

Just an observation I've made over the past 10 years ago. Why is it that designers for construction equipment do a great job of realizing that the equipment they make is likely going to occasionally have to be transported, and do a great job of providing proper & sufficient tie down points, but designers of farm, lawn & garden, and industrial equipment (forklifts specifically) don't even think about it???? This just seems like such an obvious provision to be included on all machinery that would ever have the potential to be towed on a trailer
I've hauled 2 different lawn mowers in the past week, and neither of them have tie down points that won't completely mangle a strap. One is a residential mower, so I sort of get it there, but the other is a Kubota ZD326, which is an commercial machine. There is literally nowhere on the machine you can pass a strap that is both non abrasive to a strap, and of sufficient strength to do so. I also saw this same tendency on forklifts when I was in that business. Sit down machines aren't bad, but the stand-up lifts have no securement points to be found. Crazy part is on those machines, the single biggest buyers of them are the dealers, which put them in their rental fleets, which automatically means they are going to have to be properly secured on a regular basis.
I've hauled 2 different lawn mowers in the past week, and neither of them have tie down points that won't completely mangle a strap. One is a residential mower, so I sort of get it there, but the other is a Kubota ZD326, which is an commercial machine. There is literally nowhere on the machine you can pass a strap that is both non abrasive to a strap, and of sufficient strength to do so. I also saw this same tendency on forklifts when I was in that business. Sit down machines aren't bad, but the stand-up lifts have no securement points to be found. Crazy part is on those machines, the single biggest buyers of them are the dealers, which put them in their rental fleets, which automatically means they are going to have to be properly secured on a regular basis.
#2
Senior Member

Maybe on the forklifts they figure you can run straps through the boom/forks and most I've seen have a pin in the back for straps. My John Deere 930M has places specifically for tie downs so maybe an oversight by Kubota?
#4
Senior Member



Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Suburb of Sugar Tit SC
Posts: 14,493
Received 9,282 Likes
on
5,026 Posts

This is very much the case for sit down lifts, but not at all the case for stand up lifts/electric pallet jacks (combined they are roughly 50% of the market). Worst part in them, you can easily damage them in the process of getting them legally, and safely secured.
#7
Senior Member


Just an observation I've made over the past 10 years ago. Why is it that designers for construction equipment do a great job of realizing that the equipment they make is likely going to occasionally have to be transported, and do a great job of providing proper & sufficient tie down points, but designers of farm, lawn & garden, and industrial equipment (forklifts specifically) don't even think about it???? This just seems like such an obvious provision to be included on all machinery that would ever have the potential to be towed on a trailer
I've hauled 2 different lawn mowers in the past week, and neither of them have tie down points that won't completely mangle a strap. One is a residential mower, so I sort of get it there, but the other is a Kubota ZD326, which is an commercial machine. There is literally nowhere on the machine you can pass a strap that is both non abrasive to a strap, and of sufficient strength to do so. I also saw this same tendency on forklifts when I was in that business. Sit down machines aren't bad, but the stand-up lifts have no securement points to be found. Crazy part is on those machines, the single biggest buyers of them are the dealers, which put them in their rental fleets, which automatically means they are going to have to be properly secured on a regular basis.
I've hauled 2 different lawn mowers in the past week, and neither of them have tie down points that won't completely mangle a strap. One is a residential mower, so I sort of get it there, but the other is a Kubota ZD326, which is an commercial machine. There is literally nowhere on the machine you can pass a strap that is both non abrasive to a strap, and of sufficient strength to do so. I also saw this same tendency on forklifts when I was in that business. Sit down machines aren't bad, but the stand-up lifts have no securement points to be found. Crazy part is on those machines, the single biggest buyers of them are the dealers, which put them in their rental fleets, which automatically means they are going to have to be properly secured on a regular basis.
#9
THT Sponsor


Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Wisconsin And Marathon,Fl
Posts: 9,205
Received 2,546 Likes
on
1,157 Posts

I hear you. I bought my forklift in Georgia and had it shipped to Wisconsin. I had 4 heavy duty lay flat rings welded on before it left Georgia. Something I felt the manufacturer should have done.
#10
Senior Member

Just an observation I've made over the past 10 years ago. Why is it that designers for construction equipment do a great job of realizing that the equipment they make is likely going to occasionally have to be transported, and do a great job of providing proper & sufficient tie down points, but designers of farm, lawn & garden, and industrial equipment (forklifts specifically) don't even think about it???? This just seems like such an obvious provision to be included on all machinery that would ever have the potential to be towed on a trailer
I've hauled 2 different lawn mowers in the past week, and neither of them have tie down points that won't completely mangle a strap. One is a residential mower, so I sort of get it there, but the other is a Kubota ZD326, which is an commercial machine. There is literally nowhere on the machine you can pass a strap that is both non abrasive to a strap, and of sufficient strength to do so. I also saw this same tendency on forklifts when I was in that business. Sit down machines aren't bad, but the stand-up lifts have no securement points to be found. Crazy part is on those machines, the single biggest buyers of them are the dealers, which put them in their rental fleets, which automatically means they are going to have to be properly secured on a regular basis.
I've hauled 2 different lawn mowers in the past week, and neither of them have tie down points that won't completely mangle a strap. One is a residential mower, so I sort of get it there, but the other is a Kubota ZD326, which is an commercial machine. There is literally nowhere on the machine you can pass a strap that is both non abrasive to a strap, and of sufficient strength to do so. I also saw this same tendency on forklifts when I was in that business. Sit down machines aren't bad, but the stand-up lifts have no securement points to be found. Crazy part is on those machines, the single biggest buyers of them are the dealers, which put them in their rental fleets, which automatically means they are going to have to be properly secured on a regular basis.
#11
Senior Member



Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Suburb of Sugar Tit SC
Posts: 14,493
Received 9,282 Likes
on
5,026 Posts

Believe it or not standard MO for shipping forklifts is to ship them in box vans with wooden block nailed in the floor around them. No straps at all. Only thing between them and falling on the roof of other cars is a few nails, some thin sheet metal trailer walls, and a good truck driver.
#14
Senior Member



Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Suburb of Sugar Tit SC
Posts: 14,493
Received 9,282 Likes
on
5,026 Posts
#15
Member

They move plenty if I don't strap mine down good luck getting them back off they will jam themselves together on the trailer it takes less time to secure them correctly then to untangle them. Exmark has built in tie down points so no reason not to strap them down.
#17
Senior Member

My Scag has some tie down points I think, I usually just go through the frame, easy enough. It will bounce around some but not horribly if not strapped in an enclosed trailer or so I have heard. Seen too many pictures of boats on top of trucks to risk not securing it in the event of an accident. Would at least damage other stuff in the trailer if not fly out. Still not as set up as our construction stuff at work.
#18
Senior Member
