Any unhappy Evinrude G2 owners out there?
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter

There's been no shortage of threads comparing one O/B to another one. This isn't a comparison thread. I just want to know if you own or have owned the new Gen2 Evinrudes and your satisfaction with them. Only first hand knowledge. I don't want to know about your uncle's friend's brother-in-law that had one blow up. Only owners or past owners.
Getting ready to build another boat and the G2 250 H.O. or G2 300 is beginning to pick up my interest.
Getting ready to build another boat and the G2 250 H.O. or G2 300 is beginning to pick up my interest.
#2
Senior Member

Yeah,,,, I,m unhappy I don't have them......
Likes:
#3
Senior Member

Sorry cant help you. I'm just a poor G1 owner with no issues or excuse to the wife why I need a G2
Likes:
#4
Senior Member

I took a demo ride on a ‘26 wellcraft CC that had a pair of 225s or 250s G2s. It accelerated like a wave runner. Topped out at 55/56, and the driver didn’t spend much time playing with the trim so I don’t know if it had more left.
Aside from that, I don’t own them and can’t tell you about reliability or ownership.
Aside from that, I don’t own them and can’t tell you about reliability or ownership.
#5
Admirals Club 


Auto trim is standard on the G2 - there really isn't any good reason for anyone other than a pro driver to play with the trim except in rough sea conditions.
#6
Senior Member


Fantastic engine, excellent power, good on fuel, low oil consumption using xd 100. Power steering is excellent. Quite happy with the engine. Had a Ficht and that was good engine for 15 years until the very end. G-2, start engine and go fishing. I have written a few times about the engine on other posts, check them out. Not a fan boy, just had a relatively heavy hull to move. Actually is quick now and have warn passengers to hold on, did not have to do that with the Ficht.
Likes:
#7
Admirals Club 

Join Date: May 2011
Location: Louisiana and Morehead City N.C.
Posts: 12,674
Received 1,371 Likes
on
974 Posts

Have posted on a quite a few of these threads.
Love my G2. Just a different animal than a 4 stroke.
Wanted something different and 10 year warranty.
Evinrude stands behind their products.
Love my G2. Just a different animal than a 4 stroke.
Wanted something different and 10 year warranty.
Evinrude stands behind their products.
#8
Senior Member
Thread Starter

Fantastic engine, excellent power, good on fuel, low oil consumption using xd 100. Power steering is excellent. Quite happy with the engine. Had a Ficht and that was good engine for 15 years until the very end. G-2, start engine and go fishing. I have written a few times about the engine on other posts, check them out. Not a fan boy, just had a relatively heavy hull to move. Actually is quick now and have warn passengers to hold on, did not have to do that with the Ficht.
I've heard this from quite a few people. 1. They love their G2 and 2. Evinrude bends over backwards to keep their customers happy when there is a problem.
#9
Admirals Club 

Join Date: May 2011
Location: Louisiana and Morehead City N.C.
Posts: 12,674
Received 1,371 Likes
on
974 Posts

The G2's are made to run on XD100. Dont think they reccomend anything different. At 30 dollars or so a gallon and the amount they burn its not bad at all.
But it seems like the pricing for G2's is all over the place.
But it seems like the pricing for G2's is all over the place.
#10
Senior Member

#11
Senior Member


It can be programmed by the dealer with the software to run oil other than xd100, they don't recommend that if you boat in cold temperatures, that should not apply to you. For the amount of oil you use and how clean it runs, I will always run xd100. On a side note, prior to me buying the boat I run, in 2008 BRP replaced the EMM, even though the engine was way out of warranty and they did not even own the company when the engine was manufactured. That spoke volumes as the their level of trying to do the right thing. Also Seahorse as a resource on all the posting boards and their owners website is another level of comfort. I think all manufacturers make good engines now, it just what will work for you, your boating style/needs, and whether you want to pour or change oil. I don't think you can go wrong with any of the choices out there. Best of luck.
Last edited by stripa; 11-18-2017 at 04:55 AM.
#12
Admirals Club 


I love my G2 300s. Had them on new sled since August and now 115 hours of pure awesomeness. My last boat had twin 300 second generation Verados. I'll never go back as the power, torque, efficiency and maintenance schedule I now have have made my fishing habit pure joy! Ten year warranty with no hours exclusion here in Florida and Evinrude stands behind their engines.
Twice Blessed
Twice Blessed
#13
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Michigan-Ohio Line, Lake Erie
Posts: 995
Received 198 Likes
on
117 Posts

Absolutely LOVE my 2017 150hp G2 HO as I have posted many times on many forums. I put her to bed this week with 141 hours and figured that I burned just shy of 5 gallons of oil for the year. The 10 year warranty is a big reason people jumped on these and from what I have read they back this very well.....don't want to know personally. I have played with a couple of other boaters (3)with other 150's and blew them out of the water without having to run full throttle. We had planned the course, lined up and I let the them get hole shot and then blew past and did again but this time I got hole shot and never looked back. One of these were a Cabela's fisherman and got to know him well thru summer so my G2 made me a new fishing buddy with great tips.
The ONLY thing I would negotiate and ask alot of questions about on my next one is the computerized operator gauge.the brain. I have the 3.5" Evinrude screen but not all options are hooked up. Mine only shows the engine temp, the hours, the oil level and the engine tilt percentage. Other G2 owners have theirs that shows all including miles to empty, GPH, trip logs, and many other things I wish I had. My next one will show everything that motor is doing at a touch of a button because upgrading now would cost me big $$$.
I'm VERY SORRY if I didn't explain this part very well but You can read about this at the Evinrude owners website:
http://www.etecownersgroup.com/categories
The ONLY thing I would negotiate and ask alot of questions about on my next one is the computerized operator gauge.the brain. I have the 3.5" Evinrude screen but not all options are hooked up. Mine only shows the engine temp, the hours, the oil level and the engine tilt percentage. Other G2 owners have theirs that shows all including miles to empty, GPH, trip logs, and many other things I wish I had. My next one will show everything that motor is doing at a touch of a button because upgrading now would cost me big $$$.
I'm VERY SORRY if I didn't explain this part very well but You can read about this at the Evinrude owners website:
http://www.etecownersgroup.com/categories
#15

I've run a total of 8 G2 300's over the past 3 yrs. Best engines I've owned to date. All were flawless. The boat ended up selling in less than 2 weeks from listing it.
Only one issue with a recall on a corroded dps sensor replaced under warranty. Never created an issue but they were replaced anyway prior to being delivered to new owner.
Our new 36 will also have trip 300 G2's. We run heavy with dive loads and the torque and fuel efficiency can't be beaten.
Also really enjoyed being able to just add a gallon of oil to each rez with each 300 gal fill and not having to deal with oil changes and service on a boat kept on a lift.
.
.
Only one issue with a recall on a corroded dps sensor replaced under warranty. Never created an issue but they were replaced anyway prior to being delivered to new owner.
Our new 36 will also have trip 300 G2's. We run heavy with dive loads and the torque and fuel efficiency can't be beaten.
Also really enjoyed being able to just add a gallon of oil to each rez with each 300 gal fill and not having to deal with oil changes and service on a boat kept on a lift.
.
.
Last edited by OffshoreApparel.com; 11-18-2017 at 06:14 AM.
Likes:
#16
Admirals Club 


Only 5 gallons for 141 hours?! Damn. I must be doing something wrong. I got twin 250 HO pushing my GW Marlin and am putting in a gallon in each for every tank full (give or take). Long runs out to the tuna grounds. Getting about 1.3 to 1.5 depending on cruise speed but usually at 4500 rpms going 35. Love the motors and power they have.
#17

Only 5 gallons for 141 hours?! Damn. I must be doing something wrong. I got twin 250 HO pushing my GW Marlin and am putting in a gallon in each for every tank full (give or take). Long runs out to the tuna grounds. Getting about 1.3 to 1.5 depending on cruise speed but usually at 4500 rpms going 35. Love the motors and power they have.
#19

I think it depends on the model because the 200 HO is actually the lowest output on the 3.4L platform. The "HO" on that model is intended to distinguish it from the 2.7L 200.
#20
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Michigan-Ohio Line, Lake Erie
Posts: 995
Received 198 Likes
on
117 Posts

Only 5 gallons for 141 hours?! Damn. I must be doing something wrong. I got twin 250 HO pushing my GW Marlin and am putting in a gallon in each for every tank full (give or take). Long runs out to the tuna grounds. Getting about 1.3 to 1.5 depending on cruise speed but usually at 4500 rpms going 35. Love the motors and power they have.
I only run my motor 15-30 minutes at variable speeds to get to the fish so I don't run it hard.
Lake Erie dosn't allow wide open speeds very often.