Hi Andy,
As long as we are sure that the pump is getting good power, i.e. good hot lead and ground, it sounds like the pump has a fault and is not developing enough PSI.
It is very simple to change the pump out, so as long as you are sure that the power lead and ground are good, send your name, address and phone number to me at
Tmcgow@bennetttrimtabs.com and I will send you a replacement pump. Then after you make the swap simply send back the original pump along with the packing list we send with the replacement.
Tom McGow
Bennett Marine