Mumblerone,
Think about it for a second. In the case of most outboards (if not all) the engine and the fuel lines are above the fuel tank. For a siphon to occur the fuel line has to be below the level of the fuel. Since the fuel lines are above the maximum level of the fuel in the tank, if a fuel line break were to happen the fuel will simply flow back into the tank. There cannot be a siphoning of fuel.
Is it a good idea to have a siphon valve installed? Maybe, maybe not. My personal opinion is they cause far more problems than they would ever prevent, particularly in an outboard engine installation.
And by the way, here is what the Coast Guard has published concerning use of anti-siphon valves:
Quote
This pamphlet, ?SAFETY STANDARDS FOR BACKYARD BOAT BUILDERS,? (COMTDPUB P16761.3B), is a simplified explanation of Federal recreational boat construction requirements and is intended for the use of the non-professional, individual builder. The primary objective of these requirements is to avoid certain safety hazards which have been found to be the cause of boating accidents.
Each fuel line from the fuel tank to the fuel inlet connection on the carburetor must be above the level of the tank top OR HAVE AN ANTI-SIPHON DEVICE OR AN ELECTRICALLY OPERATED FUEL STOP VALVE. End quote.
The full text of the Coast Guard publication can be found here:
http://64.233.161.104/search?q=cache...irements&hl=en
Note that I have emphasized in capital letters the key part of the text. It is an either/or situation. Either have the fuel lines routed above the top of the tank OR use an anti-siphon valve. The Coast Guard does not mandate use of an anti-siphon valve.
Another one for the myth busters file.
Here is the actual law concerning use, or non use, of anti-siphon valves:
FEDERAL LAW
183.568 - Anti-siphon protection
Each fuel line from the fuel tank to the fuel inlet connection on the carburetor must:
(a) Be above the level of the tank top; or
(b) Have an anti-siphon device or an electrically operated fuel stop valve:
(1) At the tank withdrawal fitting; or
(2) Installed so the line from the fuel tank is above the top of the tank; or
(c) Provided that the fuel tank top is below the level of the carburetor inlet, be metallic fuel lines meeting the construction requirements of Sec. 183.538 or “USCG Type A1” hose, with one or two manual shutoff valves installed as follows:
(1) Directly at the fuel tank connection arranged to be readily accessible for operation from outside the compartment, and
(2) If the length of fuel line from the tank outlet to the engine inlet is greater than 12 feet, a manual shutoff valve shall be installed at the fuel inlet connection to the engine.
"Anti-siphon protection” is a term applied to the means of preventing the siphon action of permitting fuel to continue to flow out of the fuel tank in the event there is a break or rupture in a fuel distribution line, or if a fitting in the fuel line loosens, creating a leak.
"Anti-siphon protection” may be accomplished by one or more of the following methods:
(a) Keep all parts of the fuel line from the fuel tank to the fuel line connection at the carburetor above the level of the top of the fuel tank. The tank top level is determined with the boat in its “static floating position.” Practically, the fuel pump and fuel filter(s) must also be above the tank top.
(b) Install an anti-siphon device at the tank withdrawal fitting. The fuel distribution line may then run below the level of the tank top. A filter may be installed between the fuel tank withdrawal fitting and the anti-siphon device.
NOTES:
Some anti-siphon devices are spring loaded check valves. These valves have a specific cracking pressure and provide protection up to a specific head. Therefore, the anti-siphon valve must be selected or ordered to protect against the siphon head for a particular installation.
Too high a cracking pressure may cause vapor lock. This has become an increasing problem with reformulated gasoline (RFG). Be sure to select the correct cracking pressure.
Some anti-siphon devices involve a bleed hole in the fuel pick-up tube, near the top of the fuel tank. The size of the hose is critical for a particular application. Each installation using this type of protection must be evaluated to assure its effectiveness. Too large a hole will bleed excessive air into the fuel flow effecting engine operation. Too small a hole may not stop fuel flow in the event of a fuel leak. This installation is used very infrequently because of inherent problems that may result.
(c) Install an anti-siphon device at a location where a line from the fuel tank will no longer remain above the fuel tank top level. The anti-siphon device will then protect the portion of the line that must run below the tank top level. The portion of the line that is above the fuel tank top level will be automatically taken care of.
(d) Install an electrically operated fuel stop valve at the fuel tank withdrawal fitting. This valve requires electrical power to open and must be connected to operate only when the ignition switch is on. A filter may be installed between this valve and the fuel tank withdrawal fitting. Electrically operated fuel stop valves must comply with 183.528.
(e) Install an electrically operated fuel stop valve at the point in a fuel line where it must run lower than the fuel tank top level. This valve requires electrical power to open and must be connected to operate only when the ignition switch of the engine it serves is on. A filter may be installed between this valve and the fuel tank withdrawal fitting. Electrically operated fuel stop valves must comply with 183.528.
NOTES:
Fuel stop valves used in the fuel system, whether electrically operated or manually operated, must withstand the 2-1/2 minute fire test in accordance with 183.590.
Anti-siphon devices are not required to meet a fire test.
The fuel stop valve is required to be directly at the fuel tank connection by 183.568(c)(1) and must be installed so that it can be operated from outside the compartment. This can be accomplished with a reach rod or a long valve stem. The installation of an access panel over the valve is also permitted. However, once open, the valve must be immediately accessible inside the panel so that the operator does not have to reach through fire to shut off the fuel.
FIGURE 34 - Anti-Siphon Protection
TO COMPLY WITH THE LAW
Is the fuel distribution line above the fuel tank top level?
If not, is an anti-siphon device or an electrically operated fuel stop valve installed at the fuel tank withdrawal fitting?
If not, is an anti-siphon device or an electrically operated fuel stop valve installed at the point where the fuel distribution line goes below the fuel tank top level?