Welcome to the board . . . lots of great info here
Did I catch you right that you removed one engine or did you do both engines?
Your fuel consumption reduced by almost 50%

that truly sucks
I see that you removed the timing chain cover . . . I am not sure about your engine but when my brother and I worked on his engine the timing chain had slipped a notch . . . his engine still turned over etc. but it became a real gas guzzler
Has the overall performance and top speed of your boat changed in any other way?
Good luck solving your problem