*THE HULL TRUTH is the world's largest FREE network for the discussion of Boating & Fishing. Whether you're researching a new boat, or are a seasoned Captain, you'll find The Hull Truth Boating & Fishing Message Forum contains a wealth of information from Boaters and Sportfishermen around the world.
Welcome to the updated THT!
If you are having trouble signing in, please email feedback@thehulltruth.com with your username and we will help you. We thank you for your patience as we help you access the new site!
Random Quote: Some Hatteras owners don't like Grey Poupon.
Can't validly compare motors on an RPM to RPM basis. The F350s don't have to spin as fast to push a boat the same speed as a Verado 300. For example, triple F350s get the same fuel economy on the Everglades 350 CC as triple Verado 300s at 36 and 48 MPH according to each of the manufacturer's test reports but the F350s are turning 500 RPM slower and are pushing around more weight.
You are right that you can't compare the rpms unless you are turning the same pitch wheels and the same gear ratio. However, the most important fuel burn rates to me are idle, cruise, and wot fuel burn. I generally cruise my outboards at 4000 rpm unless I am in a hurry. I think the original poster is trying to get an idea of what it is gonna cost him to run whatever boat he buys.
__________________ 2012 Fountain 38' Open with quad 350 verados
38' Fountain TE with triple verados
233 Formula CC w/6.2 MPI Horizon
Comparing the #'s above I would go with the Verados on that boat. They burn less fuel at wot, less fuel at idle, and the same fuel at cruise. They are also gonna burn less fuel in the ocean at cruise b/c with the Yam's you are gonna have to run the tabs lower with an extra 600 lbs on the transom. Tabs will eat up some fuel.
I am an opti guy, and I bet a set of trip 300 opti's would be quite a bit better than both of the other power options.
That hull is begging for the 350 verados
__________________ 2012 Fountain 38' Open with quad 350 verados
38' Fountain TE with triple verados
233 Formula CC w/6.2 MPI Horizon
They burn less fuel at wot, less fuel at idle, and the same fuel at cruise.
I don't see it. The Verados burn less fuel at WOT because the boat is going slower. If you pull the throttles back on the F350s to 5500 RPM, they are burning fuel at the same rate as the Verados going the same speed as the Verados at WOT. At 1000 RPM, the F350s are using more fuel but also pushing the boat faster. Keep in mind that the F350 boat in this comparison is hauling around an extra 60 gallons of fuel. Burn off that 60 gallons and the fuel economy numbers will improve from what was reported
Basically, these two reports show the F350s are about dead even with the Verado 300s in the fuel consumption department. Based on these I would go with the F350s because they turn can slower to get the same speed but only if the handling of the boat isn't negatively effected by the their extra weight. There is enough of a weight difference hanging on the transom that boats with both types of motors should be run to see how they handle.
I dont believe anything I read on a manufactures site period. Its all stretched truth. The f350 are gas pigs. Not to mention why would anyone buy a boat with an unifficient hull this day and age with fuel prices as high as they are. I have a 36' Yellowfin w/trip 300 Verados. Of the top of my head here are a couple numbers.
250 gallons of fuel, 80 gallons of water, 2 people and 100 lbs of ice.
at 41 mph I burn 26 gph. = 1.6mpg
at 44 mph I burn 31 gph. = 1.4mpg
at 50 mph I burn 44 gph. = 1.2mpg
Wot 65 mph burn 89 gph. = .74mpg
At the moment the only boats I would even consider for fuel efficiency would be. Yellowfin, Fountain or Incinvible.
I could be wrong, but I thought the v-rods were about 650 lbs. wet, and the yams are about 840 lbs. wet.
I am sure the performance reports aren't dead on accurate, but the Yam boat must be spinning some high pitch props to be idling that fast, or maybe they are running in a 2 kt. current.
The extra 2.9 mph on the top end is not worth the extra 13 gph imho. But, that may be more of a result of the hull design.
Once again, I am basing my opinion on how I run my boat. 90% of my hours are at idle, efficient cruise, and wot
__________________ 2012 Fountain 38' Open with quad 350 verados
38' Fountain TE with triple verados
233 Formula CC w/6.2 MPI Horizon